O'Toole's Pub is a "no questions asked" establishment located in the small intenstine of Whitman, MA.
You're not gonna get any smarter by coming here. You're just gonna drink hard and lose even harder to their seemingly endless supply of Frosty the Doughman scratch tickets.
The beer selection is very minimal, but they are served ice @#$%ing cold.
Don't look anybody in the eye while you're in here. Just keep to yourself and keep drinking. Don't order any food. If you absolutely need to look at something, look at the TV. But don't ever ask to change the channel.
If you bring your car to this place, make sure you don't park it nose-in against the fence. The owner will make you correct this mistake before you even get a chance to order a beer. You need to park it with your tail-end alongside the street. You'll see.
Follow the rules and you'll enjoy this place. It's a worthwhile experience.
Im giving 2 stars because the first couple of times we went here service was decent. Having said that tonight I was given a hard time about using my military ID. Even the guy who looked a little like Chuck Norris, who I think was the manager asked if I had any other form of ID. Then 1 of the bartenders apparently was finish with her shift and sat at the Bar. I have no problem with a girl wanting to grab a drink after her shift but when we are sitting waiting for a drink and two bartenders are shooting the shit next to us oblivious to the fact are beers are finished I'm not pleased. Then we were are handed are tab after our second round, by the way neither of us had a drink before coming here. I little disappointed because I can walk here but I don't want to be treated like dirt unless I deserve it.
Review Source:O'toole's Pub has grown on me in the past year.  It is a Whitman townie bar.  As far as townie bars go this is better than most.  They have good quality entertainment on Friday and Saturdays.  The pizza isn't quite up to par with The Venus Cafe up the street, but it holds its own.  The beer is cold, nothing fancy on tap...but it's more of a Miller Lite/Budweiser kind of a crowd.  They have everything you want in a small bar, big horse shoe bar, a few high tops, golden tee, and a Jukebox  that downloads songs.  For the smokers they have a side fenced in area.  The parking lot is small, but you can park on the side street and not worry about getting a ticket.  The bartenders all do a great job.  They take care of their regulars, but don't make a newbie feel unwanted.  If you're in the area it's a great place to have a few cold ones.
Review Source: