Pennington Bagel Experience

Pennington bagel is a bit of a misnomer. You can definitely get your standard bagel with your schmear of cream cheese here but what you really want to get are the sandwiches. They probably make some of the best sandwiches in town. I can't give it the coveted 5 star rating but they're close.

I can't believe I waited so long before trying this place... I will report back once I explore more of their menu.

I like the bagels here and the prices are good... worth the $$

I started off ordering by asking if they toasted bagels; it is not uncommon in beach towns for no toasting. The young lady was confused about whether they had a toaster- which I thought was odd. I then spied a toaster in the back, and continued to place my order. The entire staff really look miserable and make it very apparent. Even while paying, the young lady who completed our transaction didn't say more than two words to us. After leaving and excitedly opening my bagel I discovered it had not been toasted. Thanks for not a completely unfriendly experience but also for messing up my very simple toasted bagel and cream cheese. Won't be back here EVER again.