Stopped by for the first time over the weekend and this is going to be a tradition for my family now. Â I saw all the great reviews and I absolutely HAD to try the spicy italian sandwich. Â I loved it. Â The sandwich was generously portioned, reasonably priced, and was great quality. Â It wasn't blow your socks off spicy, the pepperoncini's just gave it a bit of a kick. Â If you're a spice wimp then you won't like it, if you're a spice hound you'll be satisfied (although it could be hotter).
My wife and I bought the sandwiches and took them to go for a picnic at Fort Casey. Â Great decision. Â The sandwiches were drippier than I expected but were wrapped well enough to stay contained for the drive up. Â The cookies looked awesome, I regret not trying them. Â Also, the shop was slammed at 12:45 when we were there and we had to wait about 15 minutes for our sandwiches to be made. Â I'll bet this is abnormal, but it was worth the wait (even with a three year old and a newborn in tow).
Please note that there's a $0.45 surcharge on debit/credit transactions under $10.
Definitely worth stopping at Pickles for a sandwich.  The bahn mi sandwich rocks.  I ordered this without soy sauce to keep it from getting soggy since it was  to go.  We arrived close to closing time and they were out of baguettes, so I got this with flatbread and it was delicious.  The Greek salad was also fantastic.
Review Source: