Well, I don't know you yet Kristine, but we should speak because I've set foot in Pig Tail many a time.
Pretty much everything Kristine said is spot on, except for the bit about Deliverance and Klan meetings, and I am giving Pig Tail four stars for the very same reasons she gives it two. It takes all kinds, as they say.
I haven't been since 2007, but back then a friend of my roommate's tended bar here and we would go to chill, shoot pool and drink for dirt cheap. Back then you would actually catch a few attractive young women and men once in a while. But yeah, it was mostly middle-aged folk and old timers. I love it.
As far as the craigslist postings, I'm sure that practical joker is making references to the jukebox. I can vividly remember Uncle Kracker featuring prominently on the playlist.