Pontillo's has good pizza, it's just hit or miss on quality control. Â I've ordered a ton of pizzas ( and sometimes wings too) from here. Â Unfortunately, I always feel that I have to ask them to extra brown the crust... Still, about half the time it's underdone. Â The menu is also fairly limited, i.e. no buffalo chicken pizza. Â Regardless, I really do like Pontillo's pizza, just the quality control is severely lacking at this location. Â I'd give 3 to 4 stars if it would be more consistent. Â For Churchville, it's definitely the best pizza in town (it is worlds above Mama Mia's). Â For me, however, I've discovered Ralph & Rosies in Bergen, about 5 minutes down the road, for some amazing pizzas (including buffalo chicken).
Review Source: