I give it the 3 stars because just as the description says, Saddles is definitely A-OK.
We went here for lunch everyday after skiing, mostly due to convenience. I ordered the Saddles burger most days which came out pretty good and the fries  were delicious, except for one time when they came out completely cold. One member got the grilled cheese off of the kids menu and it came out average as well, you can't really mess up grilled cheese. The chicken salad wrap was OK as well, in my opinion they put far too many grapes which over powered the taste. They have a cappuccino machine which is always nice.
Saddles is good for a casual lunch right off of the slopes, not worthy of a special trip or anything.
This place is located in the Sheraton hotel's lobby area. The decor is new and the windows open toward the mountain. The service is friendly but they could be a little better - maybe some inexperienced wait staff. They do try though.
Good selection of bar food and sandwiches and entrees. Even better selection of cocktails perfect after a day of skiing.
I had the grilled chicken sandwich and it was good. They made a slight mistake with my order but corrected it quickly without fuss.
The deep fried peanut butter fingers looks really good so we'll have to try it next time.