Village Inn and Pub

They own two properties, the "Inn and Pub" (main building) and the "Village Retreat" (a separate complex down the street). We have stayed at both.

"The Inn and Pub"- Awesome! 5+ stars!Beautifully kept grounds, nicely furnished rooms, comfortable beds, pretty balconies, and well appointed bathrooms. Been there twice and will continue to visit. We love it!

"The Village Retreat"-3.5 stars. Lipstick on a pig... The rooms are spacious, bathrooms are nice; but, there is plenty of room for improvement. The doors are keyed entry (not card access), and their is no additional locking mechanisms from inside the room (no chain or deadbolt). The grounds of the Village Retreat are clean, but lackluster. Few, sporadically placed plants, junk stored on the side of the building (old boat covered in a plastic tarp, scrap wood, beat up cooler, etc...).  For the price per square foot, you are getting a good deal. But paying the same price to stay at the Village Retreat, as it does to stay at the main building (Inn and Pub); it does not seem like a good deal.

In summery, if you are planning on staying at the Inn and Pub, do it! Hands-down, it is among nicest hotels on the island! If you are thinking of staying at the Village Retreat, you should consider other options; but, do not rule it out if everywhere else is booked.

We came here fairly regularly for Wednesday night trivia. This is a hotel (Village Inn) but has a great little pub attached to it and everybody is welcome. RB (the main bartender) will definitely make sure you are taken care of! They don't serve food here, just FYI, only bar nuts but if you're looking for a place to drink, or play Trivia, this is a good little spot.

Cozy place in the village at SSI. Stayed in a junior suite off the front overlooking Mallory. Room was very clean and pub and inn workers were very friendly. I agree  with the other reviews the pub while very lively does produce some patron noise, but it wouldn't stop me from staying there again. It's also a short walk to the pier where I enjoyed my morning coffee.