Ambrosia

Excellent tiramisu! I also love their wine selection. Have been to the bar on the left several times and the restaurant once. The service is always good and the atmosphere is cozy and stylish. A great date venue!
Did I mention the tiramisu? You will be full, so I suggest ordering some to go. :)

chicken dishes are really good. so is their spaghetti.  I would knock off half a point for not having meatballs at all though.  I like the seafood pasta as well. My wife's favorite restaurant in indy.

Also sometimes the hostess does a poor job. we've been skipped before and then given the worst table in the house on top of that.

could use better service for the price.

Pretty good lasagna, the tables sit right on top of each other so if the restaurant is crowded you might have a hard time hearing your date talk.