The Cortland

The Cortland is almost always my first option when I'm heading out for a drink.  From local beers to infusions, there are awesome drink options. Plus the grilled cheese sandwiches hit the spot. I love that Bobby is constantly trying new things and coming up with different events. You can tell he is passionate about his business.

Since it is a small, narrow bar it can get cramped if you don't have a good spot in the back or at the bar. Thankfully there are plenty of other options on Main Street if you need a breather.

I recommend the "It's So Gouda" grilled cheese and whatever is on tap!

Bobby G. has created a safe haven for people who want to sit, relax, and enjoy their spirits.  There have been a lot of things said about The Cortland being a hipster bar.  I would say it's a bar for the average 20 or 30 something and the occasional boomer Boulton Center attendee.

It's easy to spot someone who doesn't belong.  They're the one being a dick.

I'm quite remiss in writing this review on the Cortland in Bay Shore. It was originally introduced to me by fellow multi-year Elite Yelper, Doug G., who has been a regular at the Cortland for several years. If he was paid $5 for every person he introduced to Bobby and the Cortland, he'd be ready to retire in a few weeks. I'm serious.

The Cortland literally does "Everything Right" as Doug G. says it in his review. These guys feature local beers, several house made infused liqueurs, a really fun local and simple ambience, true love and passion for everything they serve from their Jiffy Pop popcorn, house snacks and/or food that they partner up with a local restaurant (Tellulah's) which features AMAZING food (see my review).

The only negative thing I have to say about the Cortland is that I wish it was bigger! It is such an amazing place that it has gotten really popular, which can get very busy at times and you won't have a place to sit or stand. These are luxury problems and good problems to have, if you're Bobby @ the Cortland! :)

Perhaps I have one other negative thing to write - I wish it wasn't so far from where I lived!!! Again, luxury problem :)

And here's the summary...it's become one of my absolute favorite bars and they better keep up the good work (which I'm sure they'll have no problem doing as long as Bobby is around...) because we really love you, the Cortland!

THIS has been a review by Gaurav