Three words:
Best
Steak
EVER!!!
Simple out, if you enjoy great flavors, a fun menu and phenomenal service and food (and don't mind shelling out $125-$175 p couple), then you owe it to yourself to try this place.
I recommend the Cowboy Ribeye with a side of Truffle and butter sautéed mixed mushrooms and Roasted Poblano potatoes au gratin.
Reservations pretty much required a good 2-3 weeks out unless you want to eat at 8pm or later
Had a business meal with customer. First visit. They appear to do a lot of business meals at this rest. OK, nice  space/ and room for talking. Ordered two small steaks , which come with 2 sides and also ordered 1 appetizer and one salad. Steaks are pricy here, range from about $25-$50. Quality of food quite good, prepared  as requested. Beer on tap selection very good. Appetizer and salad quality ok, not great, not bad. Everything is " a la Carte".
Service was very slow however. Could never get the waiter's attention. Room was busy even for a Monday night. There are high opaque  glass partitions between rows or booths and the server never came over or saw is I guess. The bill for two entrees, 4 beers , and 2 appetizers, was $124.00 plus 20% = $148.00 tip. A little more $$ than I wanted to spend.
I had been meaning to try J Gilbert's so we went for my birthday. Â The filet was good, but not up to par Ruth Chris'. Â The blue cheese chips are good and very filling. Â The best part of the meal was definitely the loaded baked potato. Â I don't usually like the skin of a baked potato but they put coarse sea salt on it and it's amazing! Â I'd like to try the burger for lunch, but probably won't make the trip across the river for dinner again.
Review Source: