Jamestown Tavern

Jamestown Tavern, where even a non-local can feel like a local.

Stopped in here a couple of weeks ago on a blustery January afternoon.  We were looking for a place to chill out and drink a few cold ones after a day of exploring the local parks and forts.  I had previously read reviews of the Jamestown Oyster Bar and other local establishments and decided on J-town Tavern.  

Once we stepped in, I realized that this was a no frills joint.  It was a bit like what I would imagine drinking at a VFW to be like.  We were warmly greeted by the lovely bartender and given our menus.  They had a handful of beers on draft and I was offered a sample of the BBC Steel Rail but eventually ordered the Loose Cannon. Beer prices were super decent at only four dollars.  The bar was quite busy but the remainder of the restaurant was pretty empty as it was still quite early.

We received our drinks and I perused to menu.  I decided to order up some oyster, as they were only 1.40 a piece.  They had a decent menu to choose from, and all of the prices seemed fair and cheaper than you would find most other restaurants.  This place just screamed fresh seafood, as their was a fresh catch board on the right side of me on the wall, which made me feel like I must be drinking at a sea captain and crew hang out.  I do admit that most of the board was not filled out, which means it must be the off season for he fishermen of Jamestown.  The oysters I ordered did seem fresh, tasty and at great price for the area.  

All in all, this is as non-pretentious as you can get.  Sure, it may not have the ambiance of some of the other seafood joints in Jamestown, but it is perfect if you enjoy good prices, friendly staff, and good, fresh seafood and burgers.

I've been here twice for LUNCH with a friend of mine.

Both times we arrived around noon time to a pretty empty restaurant. Not uncommon in winter months. It has a pretty limited menu. Mostly sandwich type eats. They do have specials every day.

The first time was a Friday. They had a 6.00 luncheon special which was a grilled chicken sandwich topped with red peppers and mozzarella cheese on a soft bunn. French fries and pickle included. Portion was huge and it was very tasty.

The 2nd time we went, my buddy had a 6.00 special that was pasta and steamed mussels over a red sauce. Again, a HUGE portion.....tons of mussels. He totally enjoyed it.

Bottled beer was also very inexpensive compared to other local places.

My only problem with this place is the interior. I wish the current owner rehabbed it when he took it over. The place could use a rework. I'd give the food & service a 5 star if it wasn't for that.

Cheap & delicious eats! Leave your gold card home!

Service was extremely friendly. The onion rings were to die for! I ate way more than I should have. The dinner portions were huge, the salmon salad had a large piece of salmon, tons of bacon and lots of cherry tomatoes. The steak sandwich was delicious. The burger was tasty. The salmon and rice was really a great combination of flavor . Definitely our top pick for our stay in Jamestown. Only downside was not a seafood selection on menu.