Mama Mia's

Reviews & Tips

• 0

  This place has changed to be Slice Pizza Co.  I am not sure if it is under new management or not.  I stopped in for a slice and was disappointed, but I wouldn't have been surprised if I looked up the address first.  As the other reviews mentioned, this place is really only open because of the lack of competition in the area.  The pizza is sub par and the dining area is dirty.  I would recommend staying away.

  Review Source:

  Posted on 08.30.13 Andrew C.

  • Report
• 0

  Lack of competition must be the only reason this place is still open.

  Review Source:

  Posted on 10.14.10 Dave B.

  • Report
• 0

  1 star for the overall food and decor.  3 stars for the ice cream.
  
  Formerly a Krony's Pizza, Mama Mia's is a popular take-out spot in the village of Churchville.  
  
  This Mama Mia's is not related to the Mama Mia's in Geneseo, NY.
  
  During the warmer months, there is usually a small crowd of locals getting ice cream, as it is the only ice cream "stand" in the village.  The pricing is a little more expensive than one would expect for its location, but there is no competition, not that the village could handle two ice cream stands.  Serving sizes are decent and the selection is pretty good, with about a dozen or so choices.
  
  Mama Mia's is really a take-out joint.  They offer pizza, cold & hot subs, pasta dishes, wings, and other common take-out dinners.  There is a seating area available inside, but the decor lends a visitor to think its not much more than a feeding spot, to stuff your face and then run.  It is obvious the owners have not put any effort into enhancing the dinning area.   Similarly with the ordering counter/kitchen area, there are no aesthetic improvements outside of a barren retail space.  It is sad.
  
  I've only had the food once, a cheesesteak bomber (sub) and a chicken parm bomber.  The quality of the bread was piss poor, and the other ingredients/toppings were not much better.  Based on this experience I don't think I will try their pizza as Churchville has a Pontillo's.
  
  I suppose if I was terribly drunk, the food would have been fantastic, but they are open only until 9pm, so drink fast.

  Review Source:

  Posted on 07.20.10 Nathan S.

  • Report