Olde New York

Portions are huge!  Had come to state college for the annual blue and white game and decided to try this place out on a busy Friday night.  The place had plenty of seating and we got right to our table after walking in!  Very pleasant for all the hustle and bustle during that weekend.

Had ordered the wiener schnitzel and the portion was huge.  The meal included potatoes and red cabbage.  It needed some additional seasoning, but overall the meal was pretty good.  You will definitely need to get a 'to go' box for the leftovers

Whenever my parents come to visit me, this is our go-to restaurant.  The atmosphere is so comfortable and warm, probably due to the lovely fireplace in the middle of the restaurant.  You really feel at home at this restaurant.  

The pierogi's are a must.  They come in a plate of about 5, and my family of 3 devours them in no time at all.  As far as the other meals we've had there before, the food is really interesting.  There's quite a mix of German and New York styles, and it usually works very well.  The portions are very generous, I got a salad once and couldn't even finish it all.

In short, if you're looking for a fun new restaurant to try, Olde New York is not a bad bet.  You'll get a great atmosphere, good service, and food thats not amazing but you won't find much to complain about!

I've only been here once and that's enough for me.

My wings were ridiculously dry. I ordered them "hot" and they weren't hot at all. In fact, they were too sweet.

The French onion soup had a robust meaty flavor that I really liked. Skimpy on the cheese, but at least the soup itself was tasty.

The service was fine, although my mom ordered a Manhattan and the bartender completely left out the vermouth, which is kinda necessary in a cocktail with only three ingredients. I've now taken to calling this drink the "Olde New York Style Manhattan," which might sound tempting but in fact is quite disgusting. After sending it back, our waitress apologized and said that the bartender admitted to not knowing how to make the drink. So maybe stick with beer here.