The Pie Pan

This is not a fancy place as you would expect.. The staff is friendly and it has a feel that the waitresses know a lot of the customers. At checkout, the woman was on the phone chastising someone I assume was her son for not being able to find his shirt. However, the pancakes were some of the best I've had in a long time. Bacon, eggs also pretty good. Sausage overlooked. I ordered the pie. I suggest you ask for the ice cream on a separate plate unless you like you pie doused with soft serve. The cheery pie was ok, not great and a bit undercooked crust. My bill was $11. Overall, close to what was expected and I would eat there again.

I've been here several times over the years, usually with my mom.  I have not once had good service.  Not once.  They're usually mean and angry old ladies, and the food isn't good enough to put up with that.

The Pie Pan just won the Platinum award from the Courier and Press for Best Dessert.  The person that awarded them must not have taste buds because their pie is NOT GOOD.  I could have made a better pie than this, and I don't have a restaurant called THE PIE PAN!  Their food is horrible.  And I mean that.  The chicken pot pie was literally disgusting.  Stoffer's frozen pot pie is way better.  I'm disgusted that this place has won so many awards for horrible food.  Lorenzo's is where you need to go for the best dessert in Evansville.  I'm ashamed that anyone in Evansville finds this food to be edible.