Sheffield's at The Palace Saloon

Top notch, speakeasy-style saloon.  Some of the most knowledgeable bartenders I've had the pleasure of being served by.  Mixed a PERFECT Old Fashioned...right down to the cherries.  The huge ice cube in my Jameson on the "rock" was an excellent touch and I enjoyed a nice cold irish whiskey without a watered down taste.

I half expected to find a secret doorway leading to a room with bathtubs filled with gin.  Maybe I'll find it next time.

They do have a nice idea, but the lava lamps just made it look tacky. Kind of cool to have a nice hip looking place on the island, however! Never thought a place like this would exist on the island. Good drinks, good prices, but not so good music.

Headed to Sheffield's after a day of local perusing and initially I was a bit taken aback by the $3 cover and it all went downhill.  Inside it seemed like they were going for a clubby feel, but everyone was in super casual clothing.  The bar near the back only had two bartenders and the drinks were overpriced; I paid $14 for a beer and a mixed drink... I really wasn't impressed at all and would ask my friend to take me elsewhere next time I'm in town!