Stillwater is an institution. However, for some odd reason, ornery is sometimes served cold on the menu. That said, I have not ordered it, as I generally stick to the specials!
What I do like, and you'll like too, about Stillwater is the location - sitting on the water is amazing - with sailboats anchored nearby, a boat builder next door, wild horses grazing in the distance, and of course the "characters" of Beaufort engaging in conversation all together help make Stillwater a favorite.
The wine list is a nice selection of very tasty choices. Meanwhile the chef uses the freshest ingredients (think fish) to craft incredible dishes every time I visit, and my visits are becoming numerous. If the grouper is on special catch it!
Finally, I can't overlook the amazing bar, fitted with two highly talented bartenders. Try the Mojito and Painkiller (local favorite) to get you started.
Enjoy.