What's Your Beef

The ribeye and filet are a must and the cream de menthe adult dessert (not on menu) is. Nice way to finish off he meal.

I've eaten here quite a few times and going up to the window to place your order and watch the guy cut the steak is a bit gimmicky but its also kinda fun. Never had a bad meal, everyone who works there seems to be helpful and always attentive. We prefer to eat in the "library" which is next to the main dining area and a little quieter. Salad bar is tasty and since you pull the bread out of the warmer its always nice and hot. If you are not familiar with the area it is a very nice town with beautiful homes and next to the water. The restaurant is only a block or so from the Navesink River and its a nice place for a walk after a tasty meal. Its not a slick Manhattan type steak house but more of a nice neighborhood steak place for all to enjoy and pleasant evening. I could see how some pretentious folks might not like the semi self serve concept but its also different and it makes the place unique

My favorite place to grab a steak. Low key atmosphere and the steaks are awesome. Its cool that you get to go up to the grill and choose the size and type of cut you want.