Angelo's Italian Restaurant & Pizza

Unfortunately CLOSED for good :(

I've been to Angelo's quite a few times. The first few times to grab a slice, the next few to order a whole pie on my way home from work.  Even though I'm guilty of it at times I don't think its a good idea to write a (great) review until you've had a few really good experiences  The problem with this place is a lack of consistency.  On two occasions I picked up pizzas that were burned on the bottom.  I'm not sure if their oven is too hot of if they just aren't watching the pizzas carefully.  The toppings are good, counter service is fast but not what I would call overly friendly (just business like).  If they can get the consistency right they would be 4.5 stars.

To me the gold standard is still Nonna's, another new pizza place that's in Florham Park.

It turns out this place has the best pizza in the area. The owner is a very nice guy and will accommodate you with special orders. He even went so far as to put together a white clam pie for my buddy who said it was "awesome". His pizza is top notch and selection is even better. ENJOY!