Charlie Beinlich's Food & Tap

Nothing fancy but definitely good burgers.    Nice bar.  Good selection of beers.  Be sure to bring cash.  No CC's

Two words, overpriced burgers! I ordered a burger for carry-out and to my amazement, it was over $10, for an average burger, hardly any toppings. I guess adding a side of cole-slaw makes it gourmet or something. To my further amazement, I get home and my burger is missing the top bun! The chef forgot to give me the top bun to my cheeseburger! Really!? Also, I felt sick after eating the burger. I had stomach pains for hours! Never returning; avoid like the plague!

This place is just OK.  I had heard the hype about the burgers here for years, and it was not justified.  The burgers were just decent.  Nothing special and nothing worth going out of your way to try.  The chili was also just OK.  Very ketchup-y and not especially tasty.  It was a little pricey, but not overly so.  The restaurant is decorated like a northern woods bar, which was different especially for the area.  Beer selection is basically just macro-brews and a couple InBev imports.

We probably won't be back.  If someone else wanted to go, I wouldn't be opposed to it.  I just think the reputation is unjustified.