This place is great. Some would call it a hipster pub; I call it an old fashioned dive. They have a jukebox (an old school jukebox), great beers on tap (Two Hearted, Final Absolution, Fat Tire, etc.), a cool door who reads books during prime bar hours, interesting people, cool Sharpie written on the bathroom walls, etc.
The only downside is that they STILL don't accept credit cards. Get with the program dudes and you'll get that fifth star! But yeah, this place has some cajones.