Jimmy's An American Restaurant & Bar

Thank you Jimmy's for making our special night even more special!  My fiance took me here the night that we got engaged, and our server took great care of us.  The food, as always, was amazing.  We started off with the Ahi Tuna Tartare; and I had the shell steak upon recommendation of our server - it was delicious.  The bacon-jalapeno mac n' cheese is a must.  Our server brought us a volcano cake for dessert - as if we needed any more food!  Everything was amazing, including the service.  .

I would like to give this restaurant 3.5 stars, but I can't. And it just doesn't justify 4.

Service is friendly. Had dinner on the patio in July. Nice but not particularly special.

Drinks: Fabulous! Negroni with hand carved block of ice that melted VERY slowly. Beautiful and flavorful. Citrus Cooler was served in a copper mug and was very refreshing.

Grilled Peach Salad: Boring. Little bit of greens, little bit of cheese, one slice of grilled peach. Dressing barely detectable.

Rib Eye: Nice presentation over mashed potatoes and mixed vegetables. Steak was good but not great. Cooked okay - medium rare in places, but really inconsistent. Could have used more seasoning. Potatoes and veggies were good but not special in anyway.

I guess that's the theme of this review. Good but not great. A few highlights but overall not very special. And just to mention, charges on bill at end of meal for sharing dishes. Have not seen that before and it was not made clear up front as it should have been. SIGH.

The Shell Steak was to die for. Jimmy Mac with jalapenos and bacon are also killer. They give you breadsticks with mustard to dip in to start - and its so good. This is Aspen to a T