Very good pizza in fact my favorite that I have had. I usually get the thick crust (1 slice) as that is enough to feed me. Breadsticks are huge and they have these donuts  that are very delicious (not sure of the name).  My only issue is how much each topping is.  If you get more then 2 toppings on your slice it is more expensive then the pizza itself. I would suggest they lower the toppings for people like me who love to load up on them.
Review Source:Please know that I'm reviewing only the pizza and vodka sauce as take-out options, and that I've never dined in at Polito's.
I'm an East Coast gal, and I have yet to find a pizza in MIchiana that lives up to my expectations. Polito's is the first satisfying Sicilian I've encountered (man or pizza). It's worth a shot! Mangia!