Amore Pizzeria & Ristorante

The pizza was pretty good, but they lost a few stars because of the horrible atmosphere, service, and overall experience.  
They messed up our order, but instead of apologizing, the young guy behind the counter said, "oh sh*t!" and never said anything else about it.  A dirty-looking older gentleman opened the pizza box, threw on some tomatoes (only fixing half of the screw-up of our order) with aforementioned dirty-looking hands, closed the box, and then handed it to me!  I will not be back.  I understand that mistakes will be made, but this was not handled properly and I can get good pizza at another establishment.

Best pizza that I have found in Indy so far. It is reminiscent of true east coast pizza. I will definitely be back over and over again.

We've gotten take out pizza here twice and both times it was great. The stuffed pizza was almost perfect - it did need extra sauce (not sure there was any on there) and more cheese.  But still, great pizza at a reasonable price. They also sell a big variety of pizza by the slice, along with other items. They also have a pretty big dining room and both times I've been there, it has been full.  I would definately recommend.