Another visit to Fort Myers, thus another visit to the Athenian! It's a short walk from my grand-rents place, so we always stop by when I'm in town.
Now, normally, I order some kind of main which is accompanied by the largest glass of beverage you've ever seen, a breadbasket, some kind of soup, and also a dessert. It's just way too much food and we end up taking home huge portions. However, this time I chose the gyro sandwich with a side of fries and I was able to finish it all. And it didn't disappoint.
Kudos to our waitress Aleda who prevented me from ordering a gyro plate, which I never would have been able to finish. You're not getting authentic gyro meat cut off the spit here - you're getting something akin to the steak ummm's of the past (PM me if you remember what these are!) stuffed into a fluffy pita with a side of tzaziki sauce. Luckily for me, that doesn't bother me, but I know it would bother some folks who were looking for the "authentic" Greek experience. (If you want that, please go to Greece. They could use your money right now.)
Like I said before, this place is really geared toward the senior crowd and it's reflected in the menu and their daily specials. Get over it. You'll most likely find *something* that you can eat, just wade through the menu.
Next time I'm in town - I'm all over the stuffed grape leaves, Greek salad and sampler plate. Next time, Athenian, next time.
The menu is geared toward senior citizens and has very limited greek options. Â This is the least authentic greek food I have ever had and I was disappointed with my dinner. Â The greek salad was okay, but we found very little that was redeeming in the entrees. Â The employees were very nice and polite and service was quick. Â If you are looking for a "greek" experience specifically, look somewhere else.
Review Source: