We went on a whim with a craving for pizza. Â We'd tried other locations and liked them, but wanted something a little further from the college scene. Â
We had a great waitress (if you go, ask for Hannah). Â She was attentive and friendly without being constantly there; she helped us move to a table further from the AC vent, and was very nice about it; she brought our food and drinks promptly and even gave us advice when we were ordering.
The food was excellent (we got buffalo blue cheese pizza and stuffed veggie pizza), the beer was fresh and cold (she gave us extra orange slices for our Blue Moon pitcher), the salad was great... All in all, a great experience! Â We'll definitely be going back!
I'm honestly surprised at some of the one and two star reviews. Broadway is about the best NY style pizza you'll find in the area. They offer delivery but that can take almost an hour--you're better off going in or picking it up. The wings are also very good and they've got some good bar specials.
It's refreshing to see a place that makes its own pizza dough and hand-tosses it right in front of you. The entrees aren't anything special. They taste pretty much like any other Italian restaurant. Stick to items baked in the oven especially the strombolis and calzones.
The restaurant is tucked into a shopping center and you can't really see it from the street. I think if they were in a better location they would be much more popular.
We came here to watch the Thunder/Spurs game, eat some wings and have a few beers.
Pitiful service. Â We move to the bar because the waitress was exceptionally slow and the service was worse. The bartender looked like he couldn't be bothered. FINALLY the food arrived. I've eaten here many times and, honestly, the food was the same quality as it usually is, which is fine.(i had lasagna, she had wings) Â We ask for some more ranch dressing and the bartender(now our server) keeps walking by constantly(2 feet in front of us, btw) and finally, my date (who NEVER says anything bad about anybody) says: "dude, can we get our ranch dressing this f......... year?"
We ate, we left. Went over to RJ Brewski's and topped off a couple more beers.
Bottom line: food was fine, Â the service was unnecessarily bad.. UNNECESSARILY BAD.
This was a favorite of mine back when I was in high school. 6 years later, after moving away and coming back, this place is still amazing. Some of the best pizza I've ever had (I've had a lot) and never too expensive. Outdoor seating is chill and I've never waited for a table. As long as I'm in Central Florida, I'll keep coming back to this place.
Review Source:Wish they would have one out in west Orlando area! Â Kinda far for us to go, but we meet friends there and have always had a wonderful time and great food. Â The wait staff is always friendly no matter how strange our group can be. Â Never had a bad meal here and we've been here several times. Â Always hot, always delicious. Â The garlic zeppoli's are outrageously good. Â Whatever the chunk of soft bread dripping with butter and garlic and parmesan cheese is that is served with some meals is - GET IT! Â I don't care if it's 3,000 calories and 100 fat grams! Â It was worth EVERY one of them! Â I could not stop eating it. Â The appetizers are great and make a meal by themselves although we always share! Â I'm assuming they have changed managers since August 2011 cause it's great.
Review Source:I'm really surprised at the 1 and 2 star reviews. We have been here at least 5 times for a Friday night dinner with friends over the past year and always had consistent food and service.
The first couple visits we ordered pizza and it was excellent. Nice crispy crust and very flavorful. The past 3 or so visits we have had the Stromboli which was perfect! When you take a bite there is the perfect crunch of the crust surrounding the yummy gooey insides of melted cheese, pepperoni and veggies. Tonight was no exception.
Most times of the year we choose to dine outside. The ambiance is pleasant. With the cold weather we experienced tonight we were quite comfortable with the overhead heaters. The service was friendly and left nothing to complain about.
Overall, definitely worth the calories!
The food is usually pretty good, but be careful if you need to use the restrooms. Â The kitchen is right next to the hallway for the restrooms and they are very SLIPPERY. Â I was wearing sandals and slipped on the floor and hurt my foot and knee. Â Three months later, I am still having foot problems. Â They need to put a non-skid mat down in this hallway and degrease the floor.
Review Source:We've ordered from here a few times. This is a TERRIBLE Broadway location. The food is always cold, over or under-done, sloppy or just plain gross (how do you screw up a cheese pizza?). Also, I understand why College-adjacent Broadway locations take 1hr to deliver a block away. But in the Altamonte suburbs...really?
Do yourself a favor and go to one of the GOOD Broadway locations (Winter Park is my favorite), that actually make really good food.
Just terrible. Â The food can be good but is utterly inconsistent. Â Forget about calling and talking to a level-headed manager that cares. Â Once they get the credit card number you're treated like a telemarketer if you call them back. Â Sean - "the manager" - is disgraceful. Â Professionalism is out the door at this place. Â Once you have paid, it is like the older kids on the playground taking your money and holding it high and laughing at you. Â So NOT worth the aggravation of trying to resolve poor service or incorrect orders. Â This place is the roulette of Maitland/Altamonte delivery. Â If your order is so wrong you have to throw it out, they honestly don't care. Â You get charged either way. Â Why take the chance? Â Avoid this one - the poor reviews are indication enough the managers here just don't care.
Review Source:Sometimes the pizza is great, but very inconsistent. Been several times and pizza has never been the same. Sometimes burned, sometimes doughy. This time  over cooked and tons of flour on bottom. Garlic knits arwere great last time we had them, then over cooked this time. Just over all inconsistent place. Doubt we're going back again...
Review Source:I recently was here for the first time in at least a few years. It's just as good as I remember it being! I was here late at night on a Friday and was with maybe close to ten other people, many of whom were being a little loud and crazy since our group had been out to I believe 3 different bars earlier that night. We decided to sit outside since it was pretty nice out and since it didn't appear there was room for our party inside. (The inside was kind of crowded, too.)
The service was reasonably good and I appreciate our server's patience and accommodating nature, considering that our group was not being overly cooperative at times. Haha. Our server did a fine job - she got everything out to us in timely manner, considering how busy it was that night, and everything (as far as I can tell) came out accurately. I had the Oriental Chicken pizza, which consists of Mozzarella cheese, Oriental sesame ginger, onions, sweet red pepper(s) and grilled chicken. It was just as good as I was expecting and perhaps was better. I ate all of mine, save for one slice that I took home and ate the next day.
I don't hang out in this part of town too much anymore (the night in question kind of was an anomaly), but if I'm around again soon, even at a more decent hour, I may pop in here for a quick something to eat. I can safely recommend this location to all Yelpers and hope to be back again.
P.S. I've provided a picture of most of the dessert menu. Zeppolis (an Italian pastry that's kind of like a cannoli, but is more like a cake or cupcake) and a cheesecake calzone are offered. I've had Zeppolis at other places and love them, and I think it goes without saying that a cheesecake calzone would be pretty unbelievable. I hope to try dessert here if I make it back.
My favorite calzone in the Orlando area. Â Thin/crispy crust and they don't go light on the cheese. Â Service always friendly. Â Have also enjoyed the eggplant parm and the pizza's. Â They have the NFL Sunday ticket, however, only 1 large TV and two small Tv's. Â Large outdoor patio area too.
Review Source:I have nothing bad to say about this place. Service and food were great!
We ordered lots of wings, a Sicilian pizza & a NY style pizza. Everything was really good! Also, the food came out pretty fast (good thing, we were beyond starving!!!)
The wings were great - nice and crispy and just the right amount of wing sauce.
The Sicilian pizza was also delish -- crispy bottom, soft center, and lots of cheese. How could it get any better?
It's open until 4 am and they have an outdoor seating area where they play music on certain nights.
I definitely recommend.
I found this gem through suggestion of a co-worker as i do not live on this side of town. All I have to say is WoW! The pizza was phenomenal. Since then I make the 45 min drive from where i live to get pizza from here, while it is not a luxury i can take all the time. It's soooo worth it. They also have a dessert don't know what it is called but they are little balls of dough in powdered sugar with a raspberry, Which is what i chose, dipping sauce... Yumm. The atmosphere is very nice to get close with someone or to hang out with a group, or just enjoy a slice in the seating area outside.
Review Source:In our search for a local pizza place in the area, we stumbled upon Broadway. Beware, though, Google Maps doesn't have the pin in the correct place. We ended up in a deserted parking lot a few blocks away and had to call to find out where they were. It is in a shopping plaza so street numbers were useless.
This place seems like a great place for a late-night meal or snack. There are a lot of TVs, so there was a bunch of football watching and loud cheers, but we expected it.
The appetizers were good and the pizza was tasty - it was well priced and we had plenty left over. I would go back next time we're in town.
My favorite fact about Broadway is that they are open until 4:00 am Thursday through Sunday and 2:00 am the other three days. I can't tell you how many time I have had post-midnight munchies and nowhere to go (except the 24-hour grocery store and that's no fun).
Hot and cold subs are delish, as is the pizza. It's always baked to perfection with lots of cheese.
There is a full bar, which my co-workers and I take full advantage of after our shift, and the option to sit on the patio or indoors.
A really good neighborhood bar/restaurant/hang-out spot for your late night needs.
The 5 best restaurants in the 2015 Denver Restaurant Week
3,611 Views | Category: Denver
The complete list of 2015 Denver Restaurant Week businesses
1,972 Views | Category: Denver
The tourists' guide to Portillos: 5 must have dishes
3,318 Views | Category: Chicago
Pho = Pronounced "fuh" not "foe" for pho-king sake
2,915 Views | Category: Denver
Indulgery selected to exhibit at Collision Conference
2,987 Views | Category: Press Releases
Not Logged In
BUSINESSES
Local Businesses
Near Me
My Favorites
SOCIAL
Blog & News
MY ACCOUNT
Login
Register
Contact Us
Add Your Business
