To be honest I am not sure if this place is even open anymore. I walk by it all the time and it is usually dark, but then occasionally it is open. I am not sure what the deal is.
Club 58 is in a basement, and you will never forget that it is a basement while you are there. It is very basementy. I think it is even carpeted. There are pool tables and a beer pong table, but you're not allowed to play with beer so maybe that makes it Beirut? I don't know. I'm not a genius.
Cheap-ish beer. Terrible DJ's on the weekend, a terrible projection tv for watching sports. Spunky bartenders. A dark back room that you have to walk through to get to the bathrooms.
I'd be lying if i told you i hated this place, but it is a dump.