Eastchester Inn deserves a solid 2.5 stars. The wings, which I heard were delicious, are decent - nothing more, nothing less.
They seem to have a little too much hot sauce in the hot sauce to butter ratio. I also found my wings to be a little overcooked.
It's a bar with a couple of tables, and from what I could tell, the bar serves as the majority of their business.
The prices were very good, and our waitress was incredibly acccomodating. These two attributes are what made me give it 3 stars.
Would I come back here? If the wait at Candlelight and Sherwoods was too long, and I found myself back in Eastchester looking for wings, sure, why not.