If I could I would give a half star! Service SUCKED! One person got a can of soda that expired April 2012. They would not come to table to serve us. They charged me full price for half off apps. They added 2 extra beers on my tab. Went into the ladies room freezing cold and very unclean! Pizza was ok but not for $26. Only send someone to this place if you hate them.
Review Source:We used to go here all the time because they had such an excellent beer selection. They still do, but they place is just kind of a disappointment now. We never go here for breakfast, but the lunch and dinner food is average to below average. They make a big thing out of the "long dog" pizza, but it's not that special. I think square inch-wise, it's about the same as a large round pizza elsewhere, and it's way more expensive. And there's never very much meat on it. I don't mind paying a lot for something that is quality, but this isn't it.
One thing that I really like in a neighborhood bar is the ability to have a conversation over drinks with the person I'm with. This place has really loud music most of the time (I think it depends on who the bartender is) and you can't hear the other person talk. Also, there are three televisions on in this tiny place as well, for even more distraction. Maybe that makes sense on game day, but all three TVs are on, sometimes on different channels, every time I go to this place.
I think that I'm giving up on the Milton Tavern forever. Maybe I'm getting old, but The Milton Tavern experience has turned into an overpriced annoyance.