Ordered a grilled chicken Ceasar salad, it was ok but hella small and expensive for the size. Bari's Pizzeria or Brothers Pizzeria are a little further but have much better and bigger salads for the money, for the same price a My Pizza i get 2-3 times more salad and waaaaay more chicken! see the thing is that there are no other pizzeria's in close proximity to My Pizza so the can get away with the higher prices due to lack of close competition. Come on guys it's romaine lettuce a few strips of grilled chicken and some dressing on the side, a small for $9?! Not being cheap but I'll rather wait for a further place to deliver or spend the gas and drive and get the better salad. As far as the pizza I wouldn't know since I don't eat pizza (no carb diet) but the specialty slices do look delicious
Review Source:This place is hit or miss. I've only ordered delivery a few times when visiting friends who live on SI.
On a few occasions items were left out of the order, but were later delivered after we called to correct the omission.
The pizza is usually good. We've tried Alfredo, Sicilian, pepperoni, mushroom, and plain slices, as well as a multi-topping pie. Again, pizza is generally good; not great or memorable. A couple of times slices have been burnt or tasted as if they'd sat around a while before reheating.
Spinach roll is good. Friends like the garlic knots.