Papa Nick's Pizza

Not exactly sure why the reviewer below said that Papa Nick's was far from a 5! When you walk into this mom-and-pop pizza shop, the staff is always friendly and makes you feel comfortable. And yum! The food that I've ordered has always been delicious, and the sauce is amazing (it's a secret recipe!). I love their margherita and eggplant ricotta pizza :) and when they make the mac-and-cheese or bruschetta pizza, make sure you get a slice! Everything is priced decently for the Bellport area. They offer the best specialty slices. It's also wonderful to see a gluten-free pizza option. I realize that there isn't a place to sit, just a counter to stand at, but you could just sit on a bench in the town or walk/drive down to the water and enjoy it there.

Far from a 5 IMO. I dig the nice and cramped space with a window-bordering-lean-halfcounter a few feet from the ordering counter/product display and WYSIWYG kitchen, but the slices we tried didn't have me convinced. Solid slice for a neighborhood/in-town spot, but the $11.10 (forgot to check-in 'til I left when I noticed the 10% off offer) we dropped on an eggplant ricotta slice, a regular slice, a grandma slice, and a Sicilian slice could've been better spent. Nothing amazed me, with the eggplant ricotta being the best but still having some flaws eggplant-wise; none of the others were bad slices, but nothing I'd recommend as a justification for a visit if you weren't already nearby. Everyone was friendly and I got outta there fairly quickly, but ALL 6 customers who came and left during my time there seemed unhappy to be there (yet seemed to be regulars, which felt very off to me).

By far the best eggplant parm hero I've ever had.  Try it on their garlic bread. Off the hinges!