Paulie's Pizzeria

Paulie's is just edible. Been going there for years too (I grew up in Tenafly!) and have lived here and NYC all of my life. This is not great pizza.

Although the owner is a nice guy that speaks nothing of the food. I prefer another vendor who is down the street. The pizza is bigger, tastes better, and less expensive.

The pizza sitting out never looks fresh and if you go in the back it is very dirty and not clean.  I cannot recommend this place for good eats.