I don't do burgers (or any meat except fish) so my selection was limited. Tried the Salmon Teriyaki and it was tasteful. Portion size was slightly smaller than average -- still felt a little hungry afterwards and did not want dessert.
+1 for Ambiance though. They have an outside patio and we were able to bring the dog.
This Islands location is in the Manhattan Village Mall. Unless you have another reason to go to this mall, parking might be a turn off.
I went for lunch with a coworker because we were going to the Apple Store next door. There was a short wait list for a table so we ended up sitting in the bar area. The service was excellent. I had the chicken wrap and french fries and they were okay. The good part about Islands is that you know what to expect.