I want to give them between 3.5 and 4 stars.
Advice: Make a reservation.
We did not have one so we had to wait in the very crowded, loud bar downstairs for a table. I couldn't hear my husband talking from across the table and our server was exhausted and over-worked. It was a little dicey at first....
We had been to the bar on a less-busy weeknight and it was just fine. For whatever reason this particular Saturday evening was crazy!
But once we got a table upstairs, our service was excellent and the food was better than expected. The menu items seem ordinary (fried chicken and burgers?!) but it was anything but ordinary -- the chef added some surprises and the flavors were excellent. I have read they hired a new chef and if that is the case, good on him/her! It was delicious!
The decor is nice, the atmosphere upstairs is fun, but the basement bar was just too much for us on a Saturday. It was standing room only and people were elbow to elbow, making it tough to get drinks and food between all the patrons to the tables. I felt awful for our server, who kept a smile on her face despite sweating and racing back and forth between the bar and tables.
I meet some friends over Christmas here when I came back home to Indiana. Â I picked this place at random and my friends were a little worried that this place would be too trendy. Â In the end, it was just an updated, modern version of southern comfort food.
Meal: II had the pork belly with collard greens. Â I also had a few of the local brews, but I don't remember what they were.
Taste: Â I feel awful for saying this. Â I feel like what I am about to say is blasphemous; this is the best meal I have had in Indiana for a very, very long time. Â The pork belly was perfect. Â It was fatty and crunchy on the outside. Â It was perfectly seasoned. Â The collar greens (and I recommend asking for extra liquor) were the best I have ever had. Â I grew up eating collard greens in the south and when I moved to the midwest, I stopped eating them because no one knew how to cook them in Indiana. Â Every once in a while I will give a place a chance but it usually sucks. Â But the collard greens were really the highlight of the night, outside of meeting up with old friends. Â 10 out of 10.
Value: Â The portions were fair. Â Not bad but not great. Â But honestly, when a meal is so tremendously good, do portion sizes really matter? Â I know I might have a conflicting Yelp review that says otherwise, but for 10-01, I will make the exception. Â 5 out of 5.
Service/Cleanliness: Â I waited at the bar before my friends arrived. Â The bartender was extremely friendly and attentive. Â The waiter during the meal was pretty good too. Â He offered up good suggestions and gave us honest feed back and had it not been for him, I may have never ordered the pork belly. 9 out of 10.
Atmosphere: Â I likes the atmosphere a lot. Â It was chill without coming off as to0 trendy or hispterish. Â The bar was the perfect balance of liveliness and intimacy. My first fear is that this place would have a presumptuous atmosphere, but it didn't. Â 5 out of 5.
Overall: Â When I go back to Indiana, this will be the first place I visit. Â You can have your St. Elmo's, I take 10-01. Â 29 out of 30 points, 5 out of 5 stars.