First off, the crackling fire in the hearth (am I using this term properly?) warmed my heart upon entry. It was truly the cherry on top for this cozy SoBro restaurant. I've been to Mama Carolla's a handful of times and often find myself lured by not only the cozy atmosphere but their appetizers, particularly the fried ravioli (which I now make at home) and artichoke fritters. I know, how healthy, Brittany! Two fried favorites.
Upon this visit I was craving to mix it up with a pasta dish - fingers crossed that it'd be risotto. Unfortunately, risotto was accompanying their pork chop special and was unavailable on its own due to limited quantities. So, I opted for quite possibly the least healthy pasta option on the menu - pasta carbonara. The peas were delightfully crisp and refreshing! It was heavy and delicious and plenty for two. The meal came with a delicious mixed green salad and fresh bread for the table. Order wine, they have delicious offerings and well, an Italian meal is incomplete without it.
Very cozy, charming atmosphere. Greeters at the door very friendly. Food was good. I got the beef lasagna. My dinner guests  ordered the chicken lasagna and ravioli. I usually don't like to order chicken when I dine out, but his dinner looked great. So great that I'm going to order the chicken lasagna next time! My boyfriend just loved
his ravioli. The place was so charming that I would  go back based on the unique charm and atmosphere alone. I really was pleased with my experience there.
These guys don't take reservations but this place is seriously worth the wait. Real,homemade Italian food that is hard to top.
The atmosphere is also one of the selling points for me. Set entirely inside a Mission style Spanish home, tables and chairs of all shapes and sizes  are scattered throughout. Seem in cozy corners for couples, some large tables perfect for families or groups.
Make sure you have the chicken rosemary lasagna!