Overall, nothing much to rave about - good or bad.
The food was fine. Nothing exciting but not too bad. The service was ok. Our server was a bit inconsistent and slow. He forgot a bunch of stuff that I asked for and then I couldn't find him for quite some time. The selection of beer was diverse and tasty.
Solid 4 stars. I love Dogfish. It is exactly what you want from a bar; good beer, fun ambiance, and awesome bar food. I normally shy away from ordering food at a bar but here, you know that they are using good fresh ingredients and it shows in the food. Also great service.
Buffalo chicken dip- I want to eat this with a spoon and lick the bowl when I'm done. It is so good that I always order it. Every time I come, and then I get a little greedy with it.
All their burgers are excellent, and I'm a fan of the bratwurst. Pizza is unremarkable so skip it. Salads are great too, my only qualm is with the Wood Grilled Chicken, Bacon, And Shrimp Salad- give me more shrimp, damnit!
Also the crab cakes are a solid choice. A bit pricey but very good.
Overall I am never disappointed with Dogfigh so I will keep coming here.