Awful, just awful. So bad that I felt compelled to create a yelp account just to leave this review. Bun was stale, kids pizza was disgusting - right from the freezer and had no taste. Â The French fries were so overcooked and grease logged they were inedible. Â Nasty - I wish I had read the other reviews first.
Review Source:Teddy's Burger Joint gets two stars for so many different reasons.
First, it took over five minutes just to be greeted by our server once we were seated. It was around 9:00 p.m. and wasn't super busy. But she apologized and we moved on.
We started off with an appetizer which came out pretty quick, except we ordered chips with guacamole, not chips with cheese dip. It took four minutes for the person running the food to swap out nacho cheese for guacamole.
By this time, our food had arrived (so much for the appetizers). I ordered a Hawaiian Burger while the girlfriend ordered grilled cheese. The grilled cheese sandwich wasn't grilled, so our server apologized and sent it back.
The Hawaiian burger was okay, nothing too great. The fries were okay too, but the ends were a little crisp. Girlfriend didn't say too much about the grilled cheese and didn't really touch the chips and guacamole.
Our bill ended up being $30 for a Hawaiian burger ($8.95), a grilled cheese sandwich, chips and guacamole ($5), and a lemonade.
While I appreciate our server recognizing the mistakes (some of which weren't her fault), my girlfriend and I just felt like this place wasn't worth coming back to. The dining room feels large and uninviting, our food came out wrong, and it was too expensive.
If someone from Teddy's is reading this, it is crucial for your managers to be working the floor. It is impossible to know how your front of house and back of house staff are doing if you're not inspecting them. After this experience, I'll stick with Red Robin for gourmet burgers.
Decided to try Teddy's Burger Joint for lunch with 3 other co-workers today. Â While the service was friendly, it was extremely slow. Â Noticed the server chatting it up with other employees and customers while we waited around 15 minutes for our checks. Â We finally had to ask another server for our checks.
In regards to the food, I got the cheeseburger lunch special (which was only listed outside on a sign and nowhere on the menu). Â The burger was decent, but not worth what it cost. Â In addition, the food was very slow to come out, even though we were there at 1:30 after the lunch rush.
I feel if a place is open for lunch, they should make it a point to have prompt service for people who need to get back to the office.
With all the other quality burger places on the Northside of Indianapolis, I don't plan on making a return visit.
Decor was wood and steel, the tables looked like DIY kits of 4x4 and plywood. Â Premium prices for burgers felt out of place in this joint. Â The best thing about this place was that our food came quickly. Unfortunately the food was not good. Â We had a burger and a grilled tenderloin with fries. Â Neither sandwich was hot, they were barely warm and the fries were actually cold. Â Our wait staff did not come and check on us, we had to go to the bar to tell them the problem. Â They remade the fries for us and they were hot when they came out and they were seasoned this time. Â We were offered a 10% discount with the request to please try us again. Â We've had better burgers for a better price with better atmosphere. Â Try again we will not.
Review Source:Friendly service (and good recommendations for people visiting for the first time). Â Try the Teddy's with blue cheese... and get an Angry Orchard to go with it! Â My brother added a fried egg and guacamole - also delcious.
Bonuses: white or wheat buns available for you to choose from. Â Turkey, black bean, bison, veggie or beef patties to choose from. Â Nice selection of beers and wines to choose from, including local faves. Â
Clean, spacious decor (light wood, corrugated metal). Â Mostly regular-height tables, with a a few "pub-height" tables, and a bar. Â Separate playroom for kids.