We usually hit the diner next door but there was a wait so I finally got to try Andiamo's. I liked the ambiance inside. Tiny bar near the entrance with the very legit looking pizza oven behind it. I thought maybe it came over from Italy but I didn't ask.
The dining room is not too small, not too big, and had interesting paintings and lamps. Our waiter was really funny and nice and helped me very much to decide what to order. I had the special butternut squash soup and a small bianca pizza. The soup was amazing - almost more like a dessert with creme fraiche and candied walnuts. MMMM! The pizza was even better. Just the right amount of garlic and fluffy ricotta.
We didn't try dessert because we were so full but I might try next time. We will definitely be back. This is my new favorite restaurant in Newburgh.