Cascio's Tavern

It was really weird. I kid you not, we tried going here on Saturday 2/23/13 around 11:15pm (closing time is 2am) and the doors were locked but people were inside. We could see the patrons and bartender through the windows, and hear the music, but we couldn't get in. All the doors were locked and after knocking, no one came to let us in! There was no sign explaining anything, so we left and moved on to another (friendlier) establishment.  
I've been here before, many years ago, but I can't give more than one star knowing the place was open but locked their doors for some unknown reason so others could not come in. Very shady at best.

This place is awesome. $2 pint nights on Tuesdays and Thursdays, pool, darts, and beer pong. Nice deck on the back for smoking or, if weather permits, you can move the pong table out there. A little expensive on non-special nights ($3.25 for Coors, PBR, etc). Bartender Colin is a sexy animal of douche bag.