George Keeley's

Very friendly bartenders and drink was plenty strong. Heat waves happen, and unfortunately we visited during a heat wave and the place was burning up.

Probably as good as it gets for craft beer on the UWS. Sizable and fairly intriguing draft selection (20 or so taps) that's constantly changing. Bartenders are ridiculously knowledgable and friendly, and they'll let you sample any and all the brews before committing.

Bonus: The pub food is solid. Specifically, the wings are a great value - a small order ($9), when combined with a pint or two, will leave you happily stuffed.

Popped into this spot after a day at the Natural Museum of History and a meal at B. Cafe as a 3rd date. We loved this place. Very chill atmosphere, great craft beer selection, not too loud for conversation (it was a Monday night though), and darts. For decor, dollar bills adorned much of the bar area itself, and tin brewing company signs covered part of the ceiling. Really open space for a large standing room crowd, but we had no problems finding seats and getting cozy.

We didn't try anything from the food menu, but did indulge in one of my favorites- Stone Imperial Stout. I believe they had about 20 or more beers on tap. Very diverse offering as well.

The only downside to the evening, towards the end, were the two drunk twentysomething girls and a guy that kept busting our ass about being next on the dart board after our game. They came up to us three times during the same game telling us they were next but to go ahead and take our time, then continued to keep making comments behind us. Ah, I remember my first beer. This was no fault of the establishment of course, but we did leave early because of this, so it was worth noting. Could have happened anywhere and isn't included in the number of stars in my rating.

Great bar. I can see making this my UWS go to from now on.