Papa John's

I know this isn't gourmet pizza by any stretch of the imagination, but sometimes you're just in the mood for old-fashioned pizza that reminds you of college.  When we're in the mood for that, we call up Papa John's.  It's nice that you can order online and customize the order (we usually ask for light cheese and extra sauce).  We had one delivery disaster with them where they messed up our order and took an hour to bring us the replacement but all other times they've delivered the correct order, and delivered it promptly.  For delivery pizza you could do much worse.