If you're here for the Whisk(e)y selection, Barrel 44 has one of the best in town. If you can find a place dedicated specifically to Scotch or Bourbon (good luck with that in Columbus,) you may find a better selection. Otherwise Barrel 44 is hard to beat. They may not have everything that's on the Whisky menu, and they may have stuff that's not on the menu, so ask if you don't see anything you're game for. Flights are available for those who like to sample.
The food is excellent, and tough to beat at this price point. The only warning I'd offer is this: everyone says the place is casual, but you may bot be comfortable here in jeans and t-shirts. I'd advise a collared shirt at minimum.