We really enjoy this local BYO sushi restaurant in downtown Chatham. As far as NJ sushi places go in the area, this is consistently the best we've had over the many years we have been living here. Don't expect it to measure up to some of the superior NYC sushi specialists, but it definitely holds its own and will not disappoint. The live scallop sashimi appetizer is really very good and catch it while you can as they are always in limited quantity.
We went there again last night with some friends who are less than adventurous when it comes to sushi...and they have dietary restrictions. This place was a great choice because it can appeal to those who want no frills entrees like teriyaki and udon and basic rolls as well as folks like us who like to experiment with what is seasonally fresh...we almost never order rolls (hand rolls are the rare exception) and we are highly critical of sashimi and eat fairly regularly.
Mitsuba delivered once again. The service is good, prompt, friendly. The yellow-tail carpaccio appetizer is really tasty. I also like the option to have rolls done with brown rice or naruto-style (riceless, wrapped in cucumber) if you so choose. The fish is fresh, well-presented and overall this place is a pleasant dining experience. We have had so many others in the area deliver such inconsistent quality sushi/sashimi that this place is really one of the few options (in my opinion) to go in the area.