Service is great. Â But do not go their hungry for the prefix dinner menu before the show. The salmon the executive chef has on the menu is about 6 bites for 38 bucks with "so-so" desserts. Soup was good. Spend your money at any of a dozen great restaurants in downtown Millburn before your show at the Papermill until this chef gets her act together and actually feeds people for their price tag.
Review Source:The carriage house was recently renovated and it is gorgeous! I loved the artwork on the walls.
I got the pre fixe lunch with my mom, aunt and grandma before seeing A Chorus Line. For three courses it was only $20! For starters I got Baby Greens with Autumn apples & spiced pumpkin seed brittle with Dijon vinaigrette. Delish.
For my main course I got the Spinach salad with roasted chicken, pears, toasted almonds, goat cheese in pomegranate vinaigrette. This was good, but the dressing was a bit thick and probably unhealthy.
For dessert I got the trio of homemade cookies, but also tried the cobbler. Both good.
I also got an iced coffee and a nice piece of warm bread and butter which were both included in the price. A fabulous deal.
My only complaint was having two salads. I would have preferred having two non-salad choices for appetizers.
The service was very friendly.
I would definitely go back!