Il Mulino New York

I've been calling this place for a couple of weeks now to re-confirm a reservation for my wife's and my upcoming anniversary dinner; leaving messages and never getting a return phone call.

We have both wanted to go to this restaurant for a long time and have been looking forward to it.

We made the reservation through Open Table, and I received an email saying the reservation was canceled and to call the restaurant directly to re-reserve.

Well, as I said, I've been calling and leaving messages on their voicemail, which gives the regular hours, etc. and says nothing about being out of business. According to one reviews below, that appears to be the case.

Thank you to the reviewer below for letting us know. No thanks to IL Mulino.

Bye-bye and good luck.

Sooo  This place is CLOSED as of two days ago I was told by a man standing out front parking cars for the restaurant next door.  

You see, I made special birthday dinner reservations almost three weeks ago to eat here tonight.

Thanks for the heads up you are Out Of Business Il Mulino!!!! Appreciate you ruining a special occasion....  But I suppose you dont really care now do you..

Overpriced, but excellent service.  I went here with my wife for our 1 year anniversary.  The service was excellent, but the food, way underwhelming for the price.  I was extremely dissapointed as the risotto which came with both of our meals was not cooked to perfection, or even favorably and certainly not the price we were charged.  

Some positives, however, were that they gave us a free dessert for our 1 year anniversary and they also gave us a glass of limoncello each courtesy of the house.  Certainly had some nice touches, but come on, adjust your prices to a more suitable level for the quality.

I don't think I'll ever come here again but will gladly remember that overall it was a pleasant experience, with some average food.