Andrews

We stopped in here for a burger before the theater. It was A-okay but nothing special. I had the salad instead of fries and it was limp-ish but okay. Service was slow despite the restaurant being virtually empty. Place is in need of a makeover as its dark, drab and dingy, but perhaps that's what pubs are all about. Who knows?

Excellent, impressive and very deep Scotch menu, and a surprisingly deep non-Scotch whiskey and beer menu, including both Scottish and non-Scottish beers.
Scotch selection is excellent, food is above average (especially for the area), portions are generous, and the service is good.  What's not to like?  
The atmosphere is more upscale than most pubs, as are the prices.    
The bar on the first floor can get crowded and noisy, but there is also a bar on the second floor that is usually empty.
I probably wouldn't venture into the area just for St. Andrews, but if you happen to be close by, it is worth a visit, especially if you like whiskey.  In fact, if you are unfortunate enough to find yourself in the Times Square area, a Lagavulin or two at St. Andrews should help.

Good food not great. Nice dinning area upstairs and typical bar scene downstairs.