I really really wanted to like this more....
The outside of the establishment looks like a fish fry house you might find sitting on a lake. Quaint and rustic-y. The inside has a bit of an identity crisis....it looks like a partially re-designed Asian restaurant.
You order at the counter and they bring the food out to you. The staff was courteous and jovial while I was there.
Their menu states that they have a full bar, and my friend and I were looking forward to a beer with our fish/after a long day. But it seems that they have lost their liquor license for the time being and are not serving any alcohol whatsoever.
The guy who took our order offered up a suggestion, saying we could take our food next door to the Left Field Lounge. They don't mind people bringing in food and we can have our beer. The guy even offered to bring our food there instead of having us wait for it in the Fish Fry House. *That* is service, man.
The food was decent. I got the baked scrod. It was a little bland, but I'm the one who decided on baked and not fried (diet and what not...). It came with 2 sides. I got the hushpuppies (best part of the meal) and green beans (really, surprisingly spicy with a aftertaste of just butter...defeating the idea of healthier...). All in all, I've had better and I've had worse.
The atmosphere was pleasant  enough.  You order at the "bar" and seat yourself. This is pretty common a fish places up
north on the Atlantic Ocean. Service good overall. I had a Groupon, and that made a difference.
I have the fried scrod and two sides
( onion rings and salad which was decent), and my dining partner had the baked scrod with a salad and green beans for her sides. My fried fish sandwich was good, but the portion is nothing compared to, say Check's Cafe in Germantown. That goes equally for the onion rings. The baked scrod looked like am appetizer. We are healthy and in decent shape, so we don't eat a lot but is a rip off for $9.50, which was the price point for the Fried Scrod which was more ample due to the breading. The fish was flaky and cooked properly.
Happy hour is a good deal at $2.50 a pint for local craft brews.
Overall, we are luke warm on this place. There are way too many options in Louisville. Portions needs to be increased by 20% at a minimum.