Goodfellas Pizzeria

my new favorite pizza in town. staff are great, too. bar upstairs is outstanding. great beers on tap, and lots of whiskey if that's your thng. great jukebox, and just a great place to hang out, eat your pizza and drink good beer. I plan on returning frequently. I am a little hesitant to let the secret out as I would hate to see this place become overcrowded, but they definitely deserve the business.

Nice new location. Friendly service last night!!

Goodfells is a new pizza joint that has opened up in Mainstrause and if you're out enjoying a few beers and need a late night snack- Goodfellas is an okay place to go. My husband and I went out for a few drinks one Saturday night and decided to grab a small 16 inch pizza to take home. It was okay. I found that the sauce was very peppery and even with ordering extra cheese, there's not enough on there for my liking. I guess there's a shortage in the cheese world? They offer a 'pay per slice' option if you only want one piece, or you can order an actual pizza. The plus side is you can grab a beer and watch tv while you wait.
I wouldn't make it a point to go here for dinner but grabbing a slice or a whole pie on the way home from the bars is a good idea. I've never tried Lucy Blue's pizza, so I can't compare to other late night pizza joints in the area, but this does beat the heck out of Taco Bell or White Castle.